Started by _fazebook_ in Discord · Jul 25, 2026 · closed · Open in Discord ↗
Brondt -“ I was just talking with fazebook about this, and one idea i had was to have a secondary data point for each drop that helps track contribution. for example, oathplate pieces come from yama so yama kc would count as contribution towards that. the timing aspect of it is important to see if people aren't logging in”
joel via Discord · Jul 25, 2026
im trying to think about this and how to do it
joel via Discord · Jul 25, 2026
would you just want like 'Attempted x kc at y' shown in their contribution listing?
joel via Discord · Jul 25, 2026
i.e, here, show data for things they worked towards even if not completing a task
_fazebook_ via Discord · Jul 25, 2026 (edited)
So we know we need a bcp. We saw he was doing bandos at x time. He went and killed zulrah after, which was not on the list, but we remember he last worked on the bingo and got up to 20kc at this time.
_fazebook_ via Discord · Jul 25, 2026 (edited)
Not necessarily total time put into hunting the drop, because that’s probably an annoying metric.
joel via Discord · Jul 26, 2026
alright yes i understand this
joel via Discord · Jul 26, 2026
but you didn't really help answer my question of how to present it
joel via Discord · Jul 26, 2026
there are so many different cases for this as well, like if a task requires GP from any source, now every single thing any person did is "contributing"
_fazebook_ via Discord · Jul 26, 2026
I’m not thinking of other categories other than item contributions
joel via Discord · Jul 26, 2026
we'll just discuss this in voice sometime because i still dont have the answer im looking for
joel via Discord · Jul 26, 2026
dunno where or how you want this
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 26, 2026
My intention was just to have a "last seen" kind of metric, this is perfect
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 26, 2026
the idea being that if you're 5 days into a weeklong bingo and someone's last activity was 3 days ago
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 26, 2026
unless you hear from them, they're probably inactive
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 26, 2026
The larger problem is to figure out a way to calculate "bingo EHP", but that would be bespoke for each event. Or at least bespoke for each task and then have to be combined together
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 26, 2026
If your bingo tile is Muspah, but you just killed zulrah, sure your overall WOM will show EHP but for the purposes of the bingo your EHP is essentially 0
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 26, 2026
so the larger system would be a way to calculate bingo EHP for each player, but that brings in challenges for timing and how to quantify things that aren't tracked in game, but might show up as a bingo tile (you could just say dont do tiles like that, but thats lame)
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 26, 2026
timing is a challenge because the same activity might count towards EHBingo'd at the start, but not at the end after the tile was completed. or if it was a race style, the activity only counts as EHBingo'd during a certain time frame
joel via Discord · Jul 27, 2026
This would require an exquisite amount of information on average time to kill for all the various places, which we are pretty easily able to obtain from our own db except that its missing context in most cases. For example a master clue scroll box being opened does not correlate to how often someone obtains and is able to actually complete every step
joel via Discord · Jul 27, 2026
Especially considering that some people stack their caskets and open many at once, which would heavily skew data
joel via Discord · Jul 27, 2026
There's a lot available in that sense for the majority of bosses just using publicly agreed upon ehbs, but thays also give or take because who is actually doing corp at ehb rates? Nobody
joel via Discord · Jul 27, 2026
Just as an example
joel via Discord · Jul 27, 2026
Im open to ideas how to implement something like that because I think "efficient hours spent on event" is a cool metric for participation for sure, whether or not youre the one getting the rng doesnt show you that info
joel via Discord · Jul 27, 2026
And like actually physically tracking the time someone is spending is tough too because afking between a raid for varying times but still seshing tob the whole day would be hard to put into numbers, accurately and consistently
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 27, 2026
It doesn’t need to be 100% accurate, I’m mostly interested in the “progress towards bingo” aspect of it. As an extreme example, grouping 5+ at venenatis for the whole period gives you way above “ehb rates”, but if there no drops at venenatis that progress your game state at that point, your progress towards bingo is effectively zero. Just looking at EHB over the bingo time period, the venenatis people would be high on the list, while actually contributing nothing
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 27, 2026
Ehb is already a flawed metric, but at least it is a standard that can be used for measurement
joel via Discord · Jul 27, 2026
Okay. Gotcha
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 27, 2026
I’m not really worried about clues for this part, the ability to stack makes it hard to police and i don’t want to make people open their caskets for an event if they’re saving for something else
joel via Discord · Jul 27, 2026
Yeah I just kinda meant once this feature is added it has to be able to handle every possibility thrown at it, or know to ignore some of them
joel via Discord · Jul 27, 2026
Type shii
joel via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
@brondt_ I think I will try to tackle adding something like this today that gives event players a separate metric, "effort hrs" or something, add some cases to ignore such as clues, and have it calculate based off the actual average time of subsequently completed kills based on our 170m and growing db of drops
joel via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
Do you off the top of your head know of any other tasks that would be worth adding to that ignore list besides clues
joel via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
Or @_fazebook_ either of you guys since this is your ideas lol
joel via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
And would just a raw like "effort hrs" stat be what you would want when its all said and done, user-facing like the current points/etc are?
_fazebook_ via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
I apologize my participation will be pretty stretched since I won’t have my computer for probably two weeks
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
I don’t think I want it to be user facing (at first). People have gotten nasty over the hours people have put in (or rather, not put in) and I don’t want to contribute to that just yet
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
Just use this for now
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
Someone else has already done the work for figuring out efficient rates
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
And yeah faze just bought a house so his computer time is gonna be limited
joel via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
I will make whether it's visible publicly toggle-able. I added in functionality to be able to say 'x hasn't participated in 5 days' which shows up only to event managers/group admins
joel via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
& yea im using wom's, they're close enough to temple's I'm sure
joel via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
and we already leverage their api tons so
joel via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
right now this is already added but im working on getting it to handle more cases @brondt_
joel via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
just using the ehb ones though currentlyt
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
Nice! Yeah I just wanted to save you the effort of trying to calculate rates yourself
joel via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
@brondt_ now you can also toggle whether this is shown to everyone or only event admins/managers
joel via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
It should handle all cases if you see it not work lmk
brondt_ via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
Very cool. Office day for me today so any checking will have to wait until later
joel via Discord · Jul 28, 2026
No worroes
_fazebook_ via Discord · Jul 29, 2026
is this someone who was removed?
_fazebook_ via Discord · Jul 29, 2026
unknown
joel via Discord · Jul 29, 2026
Its bc of brondts acc issue I just didnt clean it up bc I knew it wss a test event
joel via Discord · Jul 29, 2026
Fixed the root there which had to do with wom updates so he won't dupe again
joel via Discord · Jul 29, 2026
But that was all accredited to his old acc
joel via Discord · Jul 29, 2026
"Acc"
joel via Discord · Jul 31, 2026
I'm gonna mark this done for now to get it out the list, just open another or a bug if something doesnt work @brondt_ @_fazebook_
This thread is closed on Discord, so replies are disabled.