Started by joel in Discord · Oct 15, 2025 · closed · Open in Discord ↗
Might make more sense to give groups the ability to own their own point tracking system instead of using points as a global "payment" system for premium features. A different monetization strategy would have to be taken, but the core logic for this all already exists;
suggested by @wiiedzminn
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
@role Don't have high expectations of getting a lot of feedback here, but wondering if anyone else has thoughts on this or a desire for their own group point system as opposed to the way its done now. Would be interested to hear how you would want that to look too.
callorfold via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
how do you mean by own point tracking system?
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
Am working otherwise would type up more but, basically changing the point system to give groups their own way to define values for certain things
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
And making it group specific, basically to allow you to leverage it to award players for their achievements or what have you
callorfold via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
hmmmm very interesting
callorfold via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
depending on what it could leverage that could be really cool
_fazebook_ via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
For boss of the week events, assigning values for each item over a specific given time period and wiped a certain time after the event would be really nice. Winner could be given a special role that’s removed after a month.
Everyone would get a participation point for getting a drop during the event which stays with their profile and begins to degrade over long times of inactivity (6 months)
_fazebook_ via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
We also have 4 ranks for the long time loyal members who have elite pb times. It would be great to identify those who have these times and what they’re missing. I don’t expect gear check to possible but time verification would be great.
_fazebook_ via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
Our main leader, mister kj, is looking to pay for a feature that would upkeep point accrual from event participation with automation and manual correction/adjustment capability.
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
I would really only be doing a system where yiu can manually input values for the things we already give points for
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
Further functionality in terms of implementing certain boss filters and stuff is way too niche and like
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
Just a lot of work really
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
I could potentially do something like this but we'd need to chat more, have him reach out to me
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
U have mentioned this to me a few times lol
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
Im all for anything, but im the only guy coding it and all of these ideas are great on paper, but theyre tens of hours of work to code, test, and deploy, so its hard for me to decide to want to do any of them when, for example, my 50+hrs into the event system was wasted :p
_fazebook_ via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
@kj0516
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
If there is enough desire behind it, ill add it, but im trying to stray from complexity where its unnecessary It would be comparatively quire easy to change the current system to be group specific and allow you to set the points to whatever, but adding all this extra botw logic and points for specific items etc is a big ask
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
Just bc its way too much on me and I have learned my lesson lol
callorfold via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
I’ll be honest, I think that would be a great implementation, I have plenty of ideas that could be incorporated into that sort of system, I did look into it myself previously from a functionality perspective as most top end clans have had something purpose built for similar requirements
callorfold via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
I’ve done something similar base on a discord xp system, but I’m limited to what the app has to offer, rather than being able to suggest (and be heard) of more niche specific osrs things.
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
I love the idea, I've always wanted the droptracker to be able to be an all-in-one for clan management/leaderboards/all things of the like
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
I just fall back to this, probably the best summary I can give on it
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
I suppose that there are sort of two conversations happening in this thread now:
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
The latter has a lot of complexity honestly. I look at it from the perspective of myself, who doesn't play anymore, and is not involved in any clans, writing code for a point system and trying to define how and where points should be able to be obtained
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
it reminds me of my work, where management decides to change shit with 0 regard to the people who actually do said shit 🤣
joel via Discord · Oct 15, 2025
If I go after something like that, I can say with a fair level of certainty it would be paywalled. It may even just be better as "it's own thing"; developed separately from this project
callorfold via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
To be honest it might be a separate thing entirely, as it wouldn't necessarily utilise the droptracker plug in, just a bot that can do all customisation and points system in itself would be amazing, and I do think people would pay for that functionality....
I know of many high end pvm clans that have there own coders / developers that have made bots for there own clan, so i guess it begs the question...
If you were to create something that can be utilised by multiple clans (i think you could paywall it) would it be completely separated data? no way of other clans getting to see eachothers configs etc?
joel via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
It would be very similar to the droptracker in that regard
joel via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
Also, it would be an extension of our bot still, to simplify tracking group memberships and also, people will want to give points for drops ,etc
joel via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
Without integration into our core system or the plugin, there is no tracking of drops etc
joel via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
And then it just becomes as manual as youre doing now with some small QOL i guess
callorfold via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
depends how you do it and how you target it though
callorfold via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
a separate bot could just run in the discord server and have members set name against it and go from there
callorfold via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
and the bot can do the work without having to have any user download plug ins, be worried about any API stuff etc
callorfold via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
then droptracker is a separate app / bot that can be run in a discord server for tracking drops
joel via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
I mean what would you be giving points for if not for things like drops, etc? Wouldn't the purpose of automating something like this really be to have the ability to set values of things automatically
joel via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
If not using it for that purpose, a standard discord point bot would basically accomplish the same thing, commands to give or take points with reason, etc
joel via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
I only ask to clarify maybe im just being dumb
joel via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
Like, the bot can do what "work" without a plugin
callorfold via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
competition wins, competition participation, discord posting, discord vcing, recruiting, learner raids, discord boosting etc etc... lots of things u can do
joel via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
Ahhh yeah that is a lot of added logic
joel via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
Not against it but I need help if im gonna start another project on top of this one that has as much functionality as that haha
joel via Discord · Oct 16, 2025
I would presume most osrs clans would also desire integrating the droptracker plugin into their points system as well, as coding an entirely separate system for tracking achievements feels pretty wasteful
joel via Discord · Oct 26, 2025
did some of this, not sure if ill actually finish but had some free time and figured id pick away.
joel via Discord · Oct 26, 2025
integration into our tracking system is easy though, the hard part is the extras mentioned so yah
wiiedzminn via Discord · Oct 26, 2025
Appreciate your efforts on this!
_fazebook_ via Discord · Apr 9, 2026
Possible to make a central place to view who has the most points in discord? Like top 10, similar to the loot leaderboard.
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
Definitely, I was considering trying to do something graphically in the same way the lootboard does.
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
A simple embed would work for now I suppose though considering my art skills are lackluster
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
Not too shabby lol.
_fazebook_ via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
1-9 is fine then it goes to 20 unless that’s intentional?
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
🤷♀️
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
Nah its just ai concept art
_fazebook_ via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
Good design
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
I noticed that earlier idk where it was going with that idea but yea I just wanted to see what it would make
_fazebook_ via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
Would like to see a both the points and loot board in the 2010 theme runelite UI design
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
Easier said than done 😆
_fazebook_ via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
Yeah… could AI if you give them an art style?
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
From my experience ai works better off of a base image and a thorough explanation
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
Here's what I gave the free version of chatgpt to make that concept
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
ChatGPT
Open the ChatGPT app
Try the full app experience
Open
Uploaded image
I want to generate a similarly-styled image to be used for a different purpose. As you can see from the attached image, there are 32 slots on the top, and then beneath the text reading 'Recent Submissions', another 12 slots exist. These currently host images of items that fall in order of value based on a group's accumulated drops inside my application. That being said, the new image we are going to be generating will be slightly different, with its focus being on presenting a visual method of displaying the top players based on points earned in a group. This means that items and other images may be less available, or not at all, for some of the submissions, which means it will primarily just be a leaderboard layout, with the actual entries blank like the above image so that we can fill them programmatically. ```
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
Meant to send that pic
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
I used this as the baseline
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
When it comes to prompting for images u just gotta be really specific about what youre making and even then its kinda iffy a lot of the times.
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
That one for points is one of the better ones ive ever had it make tbh
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
I never could get anything good out of it for the board in the beginning so I just used a bank screenshot and then our old artist Smoke designed the current board to be more structured
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
Im not terrible in photoshop it just takes me 10x what it would take someone who does it regularly
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
And I think I lack the creative aspect for a lot of it . Anyways I digress this kinda got off topic lul
_fazebook_ via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
If I give an image can you make it into a template?
_fazebook_ via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
Like just import
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
it has to be the exact dimensions and layout of our existing one else there would be more work to be done to create a grid of coordinates for the bot to insert data at
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
unless you mean for the points specifically, that hasnt been done yet so theoretically yes
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
but that would come with me potentailly then using your image for anyone else subbed
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
b/c i cba doing it twice for the coords xd
_fazebook_ via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
Either or. That’d be fine.
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
i can always polish this one up myself
_fazebook_ via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
Not going to rabbit hole this topic more here but this template from managing miscellania would be neat
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
im not sure i understand how displaying a leaderboard of points would be done there though
joel via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
do you just mean that scroll-like background?
_fazebook_ via Discord · Apr 11, 2026
This would be for loot board
This thread is closed on Discord, so replies are disabled.